May was a big month for solar power announcements in Africa. Algeria endorsed a huge 4GW, five-year solar plan that will install 10 times the nation’s solar power capacity for an investment of $3.2bn-$3.6bn. Further south, there were significant developments on either side of the Zambezi. Zimbabwe announced an invitation to bid for 500MW of solar capacity across several locations, which is important considering Zimbabwe’s effective total power capacity is under 1,000MW. A few days later, Zambian state-owned electricity company Zesco announced that it had signed contracts totalling $548m with PowerChina for the development of 600MW of solar power plants.
The technology-driven energy transition is unstoppable
As solar gets ever cheaper, it will inevitably spread across Africa, as it is doing around the world. The technology-driven energy transition is unstoppable. The scale of the recent announcements is worthy of note. Zambia has been among Africa’s utility-scale solar pioneers, with its first projects in the 30MW to 50MW range. In 2019, Zambia was host to a record low solar price for Sub-Saharan Africa at less than $40/MWh. Now, solar initiatives 10 times larger than its initial projects are under way.
The Zambian announcement was also significant for another reason: its contractor. PowerChina’s involvement in a large African solar project follows the announcement in February by China Gezhouba Group of a plan for 500MW of solar power in Uganda. These Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) forays into African solar come as some of China’s coal plans on the continent face setbacks.
THE CHINESE-BACKED 6.6GW HAMRAWEIN COAL POWER PROJECT IN EGYPT WAS SHELVED this year due to concerns about overcapacity and a preference for renewable energy. And Kenya’s Lamu coal power proposal, intended to be financed by the giant Chinese state-owned commercial bank Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), remains beset by planning woes in the face of strong local opposition.
However, though PowerChina may be about to construct 600MW across Zambia, over in Zimbabwe it’s contracted to build the first 700MW of the 2,800MW Sengwa coal-fired power proposal for gold miner and metal refiner RioZim. And in an agreement announced in April, China Gezhouba is set to construct the remaining 2,100MW of the Sengwa proposal. ICBC is again reportedly involved in financing the $3bn proposal.
Proceeding with the Sengwa coal-fired project makes little sense given the cost
A determination to proceed with the Sengwa project makes little sense given the cost, the loans needed to finance it and the growing financial risks of coal investment. It makes even less sense when you consider the specifics of the project. Both Zimbabwe and Zambia need to diversify away from a reliance on hydropower plants at the Kariba Dam. A long-running drought has recently led to power shortages across both nations. Low water levels at the dam have seen the effective power capacity of Zimbabwe’s largest power source reduced from 1,000MW to 600MW.
In this context, a decision to diversify away from over-reliance on drought-afflicted hydro by building a coal-fired power plant that will rely on water from the Kariba Dam seems questionable at best. Solar power looks far better placed to help Zimbabwe reduce over-reliance on Kariba as well as on power imports from [South Africa]’s Eskom.
RIOZIM APPEARS TO AGREE ON THE MERITS OF SOLAR POWER; it is planning 178MW of solar power to meet its own power needs and make it independent of power utility Zesa. The company is facing power shortages that are imperilling its future, along with a lack of foreign currency and hyperinflation of the Zimbabwe dollar. These difficult and big issues raise doubts about the company’s ability to take on such a large project as the Sengwa coal plant and even about the future of the company itself.
In its adverse opinion of RioZim’s 2018 financial accounts, auditors EY noted that lack of foreign currency and subsequent operational shutdowns were negatively affecting cash flows and raising doubt about the company’s ability to continue as a going concern. The 2019 audit opinion has not been disclosed electronically in RioZim’s abridged financial results for last year, but power shortages limited production at its gold mines in addition to foreign currency shortages due to a lack of gold receipts in US dollars.
RioZim has identified solar as the solution to its own power shortage woes
RioZim has already identified solar power as the solution to its own power shortage woes. If it attempts to continue its China-backed coal power proposal, RioZim and China risk leaving Zimbabwe with incompatible power technologies.
With ever-cheaper solar set to spread quickly, sub-Saharan nations will shortly find that renewable energy makes up a large proportion of their small overall power capacities. This will require an immediate need to balance the intermittency of renewables, a task coal-fired power is ill-equipped to do given that it cannot ramp power output up and down quickly.
China’s increasingly ill-suited coal investments on the continent risk leaving nations with expensive and incompatible coal power stations along with unsustainable loan payments.
Simon Nicholas is an energy finance analyst at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis.
This op-ed appeared on June 18, 2020 in South Africa’s Business Day: Renewable energy is starting to find its place in the African sun
Zambia’s state-owned utility contracts with Power China to develop 600MW of solar generation
IEEFA Asia: Chinese coal projects continue as existing power plants stand idle
IEEFA Africa: Coal power in Mozambique out-of-date before it begins construction