New Fortress Energy recently announced that it would temporarily stop shipping gas to Puerto Rico, revealing major flaws in the company’s gas supply contract with the island.
The contract caps New Fortress’s liability for damages. It likely has already exceeded the cap this year, meaning that New Fortress is unlikely to incur financial penalties for its current failure.
Puerto Rico will pay at least $68 million to compensate for New Fortress’s shortfall. In addition, in 2026 alone, the contract will also force Puerto Rico to pay roughly $100 million for natural gas that its power plants do not need.
The Puerto Rican government’s plans to expand natural gas use on the island would result in even greater dependence on New Fortress. The government should change course and focus on supporting the growth of distributed renewable energy.
New Fortress Energy just informed the Puerto Rican government that it will not be able to fulfill its contractual obligation to ship gas to the island for at least the next several weeks. New Fortress is one of two natural gas suppliers for Puerto Rico’s electrical system and the only supplier to the north of the island, where it supplies the San Juan power plant and emergency generators located in the San Juan metro area.
Since March 2025, New Fortress has delivered gas to its import terminal in San Juan from its LNG export terminal in Altamira, Mexico. The Altamira terminal has been plagued by operational problems and high costs since its inception, and the company disclosed in an SEC filing on Oct. 5 that the terminal was offline due to a mechanical issue with its turbine. It did not notify the Puerto Rican government directly until Nov. 1, the day that the New Fortress floating gas storage unit supplying the island reportedly ran out of gas.
New Fortress’s failure to supply natural gas under its contract means that the island will be forced to purchase diesel fuel or liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the spot market, significantly boosting fuel costs for the island’s power customers.
This latest in a series of failures by New Fortress highlights the major flaws in the seven-year gas supply agreement that the government of Puerto Rico signed with the company in December 2025.
New Fortress failed to supply natural gas from Sept. 16 through Oct. 13. In a court filing, the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA) said the delivery shortfall forced the electrical system to pay $32 million more for replacement diesel fuel than it would have paid for LNG under the contract. Other fuel shortfalls earlier in the year forced PREPA to pay an additional $14 million in excess fuel costs, for a total of $46 million for the year so far.
If New Fortress cannot deliver fuel through November, Puerto Rico will need to spend another $68 million to purchase diesel instead of LNG. If the shortfall lasts through the end of the year, Puerto Rico will suffer almost $150 million in excess costs, or about 1 cent/kilowatt-hour (kWh). If that happens, Puerto Rico would face almost $200 million in excess fuel costs due to New Fortress’s failure to deliver LNG reliably in 2026.

According to its contract, New Fortress is liable to pay for the cost difference between natural gas and the replacement fuel Puerto Rico is forced to use, unless it can successfully justify in court its failure to supply gas as due to events outside its control (“force majeure”). But the contract also limits the company’s liability to $40 million per year— $6 million less than Puerto Rico had already incurred by Nov. 1—unless a court determines that New Fortress “willfully abandoned” its contractual obligations. This means that if the court rules that New Fortress is liable for its previous shortfalls this year, the company may face no financial penalty for its current shortfall and have no financial incentive to improve its performance for the rest of the year.
Although $46 million in excess fuel costs have already been incurred due to New Fortress’s failures to deliver fuel earlier in the year, the Puerto Rico Energy Bureau has delayed charging ratepayers for part of this amount, hoping that money can instead be recovered from New Fortress. This approach is reasonable but worsens the electrical system’s liquidity problems, since fuel has been purchased but no revenue collected to cover the expense.
It is deeply ironic that despite touting a massive opportunity to expand natural gas supply to the island to its investors, New Fortress isn’t even capable of meeting its current contractual obligations.
The cap on damages is not the only major flaw in New Fortress’s contract, however. As IEEFA warned last year when the contract was signed, the take-or-pay contract obligates Puerto Rico to pay for more gas than the electrical system needs. This prediction has turned out to be correct.
Each month, Genera—the New Fortress Energy subsidiary that operates some of Puerto Rico’s power plants under a long-term contract—makes a commitment to purchase a certain quantity of gas for the month based on how much it expects its power plants to need.
At the end of the year, if the sum of these monthly commitments is less than the minimum take-or-pay obligation specified in the contract (45 trillion British thermal units, or BTUs, for the first contract year), Puerto Rico must make up the difference. Genera estimates that Puerto Rico will fall short by 6.5 trillion BTUs this year, resulting in a payment of $73 million to New Fortress for gas that it did not need. That translates to an additional rate increase of about 0.5 cents/kWh.
Puerto Rico also pays a monthly fee to New Fortress if its actual gas consumption in any month falls short of the consumption commitment made at the beginning of that month (unless the reason for the shortfall is New Fortress’s failure to deliver gas). From Dec. 5, 2025 (the day the contract started) through Sept. 30, 2026, these monthly fees have totaled an additional $24 million.
Added to the estimated $73 million penalty for the year, Puerto Rico will likely incur nearly $100 million in charges for unneeded gas in the first contract year.
This is the first gas supply contract that the government of Puerto Rico has signed with New Fortress that obligates Puerto Rico to pay for an annual minimum volume of gas, and to pay for 100% of the gas that it commits to buy at the beginning of each month. Prior contracts did not contain any annual volume commitments. A March 2024 contract did not impose any fees for using less gas than expected on a monthly basis, and another signed in March 2019 required Puerto Rico to pay 85% (not 100%) of any monthly shortfalls.
Can Puerto Rico terminate this onerous contract? One of the grounds for termination under the contract is if New Fortress exceeds its liability cap ($40 million) in any given contract year. If a court finds that New Fortress is liable for damages due to its failures to supply gas this year, it appears that the government of Puerto Rico could seek to terminate the contract.
Right now, however, the Puerto Rican government’s plans to expand natural gas use on the island would result in greater dependence on New Fortress. New Fortress already has the contract to supply natural gas to the new 530-megawatt (MW) Energiza natural gas plant that was approved in December 2024 (although it is not clear if or when this plant will come online).
It is past time for Puerto Rico to change course, to focus on supporting the growth of rooftop solar and storage and abandon its dependence on New Fortress, a company that has proven time and again to be an unreliable and costly business partner.